Analysis of the inter-annual variability and southward expansion of red tides in Zhejiang coastal waters from 1981 to 2018
Abstract: A time series dataset spanning 39 years (1981 to 2018) on red tide events in Zhejiang coastal waters was used to study the characteristics of inter-annual spatial and temporal variations. A distinct inter-annual pattern characterized by low frequency, explosive growth and fluctuating decline stages was found over the studied time scale. Most red tide events occurred in parallel to the bathymetric contour, and 95.4% were located to the west of the 50-m isobath. Additionally, the high-incidence area of red tides is expanding southward. In this paper, local sea surface temperature (SST), mariculture area and secondary industry growth rate are introduced and identified as the main factors influencing the nutrient and hydrometeorological conditions. A multivariate nonlinear regression equation based on these factors was constructed, and the goodness of fit coefficient was 0.907. The causes of the annual variation and high-frequency area in the southward expansion were quantitatively analyzed based on the proposed regression model. Finally, the results indicated that 68.7% of the annual occurrence variation of red tide was due to the SST and mariculture area, which are the main impact factors; however, secondary industry growth could compensate for the nutrient deficiency caused by the sharp mariculture area reduction and decreased SST. The background nutrient level, which is elevated by coastal economic development, especially secondary industry, is the main determinant of the southward expansion. Although the trend of the southward expansion of high-frequency areas has not changed, the red tide frequency in coastal cities has decreased by half and remained at a stable level after 2010 due to substantial economic restructuring and environmental protection.
Table 1. List of the main impact factors that are closely related to the long-term change of red tide
Data category Data record elements Data cycle Domain or station Specifications or technical standards Notes on information Red tide events Time, location, maximum area, dominant species 1981–2015 Zhejiang coastal waters Technical specifications for red tide monitoring(HY/T069—2005) Dataset from 1981 to 2006 is reorganized by the Zhejiang Ocean Monitoring and Forecasting Center, and dataset from 2007 to 2015 is provided by the Zhejiang Ocean Monitoring and Forecasting Center. 2016–2018 Monitoring data of 2016–2018 is provided by East China Sea Monitoring Center. Marine hydrometeorology SST 1981–2018 Shengshan and Nanji stations Specification for coastal observation (GBT14914–2006) Daily operational observation data from 1981 to 2018 provided by the East China Sea Forecast Center. SSTA Sea surface temperature anomaly SSTA10a 10–year average SSTA ENSO index Niño3.4 area Monthly mean SSTA in Niño3.4 area National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (https://www.cpc.noaa.gov) Marine water environment Proportion of class IV to classes less than IV 2000–2018 Zhejiang coastal waters Sea water quality standard (GB3097–1997) Zhejiang Marine Environmental Bulletin issued by the Department of Ecology and Environment of Zhejiang Province (http://sthjt.zj.gov.cn.) Indicators of socio-economic development Gross domestic product (GDP) 1981–2018 Zhejiang Province Added-value index of primary, secondary and tertiary industries Statistical Yearbook of China issued by the State Statistical Bureau (http://data.stats.gov.cn.) Ningbo City Table 3–2 GDP development index over the years 2019 Ningbo Statistical Yearbook issued by the Ningbo Municipal Statistics Bureau (http://vod.ningbo.gov.cn/) Wenzhou City Table 1–10 GDP development index over the years 2019 Wenzhou Statistical Yearbook issued by the Wenzhou Municipal statistics bureau (http://wztjj.wenzhou.gov.cn.) Maricultural area 1981–2016 Zhejiang Province Total maricultural area for agriculture Statistical Yearbook of China issued by the State Statistical Bureau (http://data.stats.gov.cn.)
Table 2. Nonparametric test statistics of the normal distributions of red tide occurrence and factors
Factor Shapiro-Wilk Skewness Kurtosis Statistics Freedom Significance Statistics Statistics YAORT 0.835 38 0 1.34 1.215 XSST 0.957 38 0.147* 0.365 –0.344 XNino3.4 0.985 38 0.881* 0.257 –0.339 Xmar 0.923 36 0.015* 0.3 –1.416 Xwq 0.96 19 0.572* 0.577 –0.264 Xpri 0.886 38 0.001 0.674 –0.838 Xsec 0.814 38 0 0.924 –0.633 Xter 0.763 38 0 1.44 1.051 Note: * When the significance is >0.05, the factor exhibits normal or partially normal distributions.
Table 3. Rank correlation coefficient of red tide occurrence and factors
Variable code (YAORT) 7 SST Nourishment Water Quality XSST XNiño3.4 Xmar Xpri Xsec Xter Xwq 1 8 2 3 4 5 6 YAORT Correlation coefficient 1 .326* 0.107 .743** .394* .696** .461* 0.22 Sig (two-sided) . 0.046 0.524 0 0.016 0 0 0.366 N 38 38 38 36 37 37 37 19 Note: * When the confidence coefficient (two-sided test) is 0.05, the correlation is significant; ** when the confidence coefficient (two-sided test) is 0.01, the correlation is significant.
Table 4. ANOVA of the multivariate nonlinear regression equation
ANOVA Source Sum of squares Degrees of freedom Mean square Regression 26 504.633 9 2 944.959 Residual 1 410.367 26 54.245 Total before correction 27 915 35 Total after correction 15 127.543 34 Note: R2=1–(residual sum of squares)/(corrected sum of squares) = 0.907
 Cao Xinzhong. 1986. Prelimary study on the seasonal process of the coastal upwelling off Zhejiang in the east Sea, China. Journal of Fisheries of China (in Chinese), 10(1): 52–68  Chen Yanlong, Yang Jianhong, Zhao Dongzhi, et al. 2013. Quantitative study on effect of seawater temperature on specific growth rate of algal species. Marine Environmental Science (in Chinese), 32(1): 104–110  Cloern J E, Jassby A D, Thompson J K, et al. 2007. A cold phase of the East Pacific triggers new phytoplankton blooms in San Francisco Bay. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 104(47): 18561–18565. doi: 10.1073/pnas.0706151104  Deng Bangping, Zhang Haofei, He Yanlong, et al. 2017. Analysis on the relationship between the red tide events and El Nino in the East China Sea from 1981 to 2011. Ecological Science (in Chinese), 36(6): 161–164  Feng Jianfeng, Wang Hongli, Li Shengpeng. 2007. Research on prediction of phytoplankton’s density using support vector machines. Marine Environmental Science (in Chinese), 26(5): 438–441  Fu Mingzhu, Wang Zongling, Pu Xinming, et al. 2012. Changes of nutrient concentrations and N: P: Si ratios and their possible impacts on the Huanghai Sea ecosystem. Acta Oceanologica Sinica, 31(4): 1001–112  Guo Hao, Ding Dewen, Lin Feng’ao, et al. 2015. Characteristics and patterns of red tide in china coastal waters during the last 20a. Advances in Marine Science (in Chinese), 33(4): 547–558  Gao Junzhang, Liu Yalin, Lin Yi, et al. 2017. Analysis on characteristics of red tide disaster in Wenzhou coastal waters during the last 10 years. Transactions of Oceanology and Limnology (in Chinese), (4): 86–90  He Chunliang, Yang Hong. 2009. Space-time distribution of red tide events in China and its relationship with the El Niño. Journal of Shanghai Ocean University (in Chinese), 18(2): 206–211  Jing Zhiyou, Qi Yiquan, Hua Zulin. 2008. Numerical study on summer upwelling over northern continental shelf of South China Sea. Journal of Tropical Oceanography (in Chinese), 27(3): 1–8  Li Xueding. 2012. Analysis on characteristics of red tide in Fujian coastal waters during the last 10 years. Environment Science (in Chinese), 33(7): 2210–2216  Lin Jun. 2011. A modeling study of the phytoplankton dynamics off the Changjiang estuary (in Chinese) [dissertation]. Shanghai: East China Normal University  Liu Lusan, Li Zicheng, Zhou Juan, et al. 2011. Temporal and spatial distribution of red tide in Yangtze River Estuary and adjacent waters. Environmental Science (in Chinese), 32(9): 2497–2504  Long Hua, Zhou Yan, Yu Jun, et al. 2008. Analyses on harmful algal blooms in Zhejiang coastal waters from 2001 to 2007. Marine Environmental Science (in Chinese), 27(S1): 1–4  Lou Xiulin. 2010. Remote sensing observation of upwelling current in Zhejiang coastal waters and the relationship between red tide (in Chinese) [dissertation]. Qingdao: Ocean University of China  Mu Di. 2011. The study on the ecological water quality dynamic modeling of Bohai bay (in Chinese) [dissertation]. Tianjin: Tianjin University  Qi Yuzao. 2003. Red Tide Along the Coast of China. Beijing: Science Press, 3–5  Song Nanqi, Wang Nuo, Wu Nuan, et al. 2018. Temporal and spatial distribution of harmful algal blooms in the Bohai Sea during 1952-2016 based on GIS. China Environmental Science (in Chinese), 38(3): 1142–1148  Wang Hongli, Ge Gen, Li Yuelei. 2006. Research on the prediction of red tide based on the Fuzzy Neural Network. Marine Science Bulletin (in Chinese), 25(4): 36–41  Wei Guiqiu, Wang Hua, Cai Weixu, et al. 2012. 10-year retrospective analysis on the harmful algal blooms in the pearl river estuary. Marine Science Bulletin (in Chinese), 31(4): 466–474  Wen Shiyong, Zhao Dongzhi, Zhao Ling, et al. 2009. Tolerance response model of N/P ratios for red tide algae. Journal of Dalian Maritime University (in Chinese), 35(1): 118–122  Wooster W S, Zhang C I. 2004. Regime shifts in the North Pacific: early indications of the 1976-1977 event. Progress in Oceanography, 60(2-4): 183–200. doi: 10.1016/j.pocean.2004.02.005  Xu Lili, Gong Maoxun, Xu Tingting, et al. 2013. Relationships between the east Asian monsoon anomalous and the red tide occurrence frequency in the East China Sea mental factors in the Beidaihe waters of the Qinhuangdao. Marine Forecasts (in Chinese), 30(5): 8–14  Yang Hong, He Chunliang. 2009. The red tide events in the China Sea and the relationship with the temperature and El Nino. Transactions of Oceanology and Limnology (in Chinese), 2(2): 1–6  Zhang Qingtian. 2013. Review on the annual variation of red tides in China Sea. Environmental Monitoring in China (in Chinese), 29(5): 98–102  Zhao Dongzhi. 2010. The Occurrence regularity of red tide disasters in the typical waters of China. (in Chinese). Beijing: China Ocean Press.  Zhao Dongzhi, Zhang Fengshou, Zhao Ling. 2003. Detecting chlorophyll and hazard algal bloom in coastal water with normalized deference of AVHPP. Ocean Technology (in Chinese), 22(3): 30–33  Zhao Dongzhi, Zhang Fengshou, Yang Jianhong, et al. 2005. The optimized spectral bands ratio for the relation of sun-induced chlorophyll fluorescence height with high chlorophyll a concentration of algal bloom waters. Haiyang Xuebao (in Chinese), 27(6): 146–153  Zhong Shanshan, He Jinhai, Liu Xuanfei, et al. 2004. Possible mechanisms of Enso’s decadal variability. Journal of Tropical Oceanography (in Chinese), 23(2): 28–36
- 文章访问数: 5
- HTML全文浏览量: 2
- 被引次数: 0